lohud.com

Sponsored by:

Faceoff

Rick Carpiniello and Sam Borden debate the the hottest topics in sports

Question #158: How did A-Rod do today?

February
17

Hello, all. I’m back after a week in the unpaid-journalism hinterland, and it’s a pleasure to rejoin you.

Today’s question is an obvious one, as the biggest story in sports is about Alex Rodriguez. He’ll meet the media in a 1:30 p.m. press conference that is, quite literally, taking place under a tent at Steinbrenner Field in Tampa. Insert your own “circus” reference here.

A-Rod has a chance today. Not to put the steroid story completely behind him because, let’s face it, that isn’t going to happen. He is the best player in the game and he admitted that his accomplishments aren’t clean. That’s not something you wipe off in a day or even two or three.

But A-Rod can do himself, and the Yankees, a lot of good today. He’s got a ton of advisers, people who are supposed to tell him what to do to make himself look the best in the public eye. And today, that means coming clean. Here are the questions that weren’t asked by Peter Gammons on ESPN a week ago, but almost surely will be (or should be) today:

1. When, exactly, have you taken PEDs in your life? What years and for how long?
2. Who gave them to you on each occasion?
3. How is it possible that you are incredibly careful about what food you eat, among other things, yet you don’t remember what substances you ingested when you were taking PEDs?
4. Do you believe you cheated?

These are just the top few that come to mind. What questions would you ask? Let’s see what Carp is looking for today and then be sure to check back throughout the day for reviews of A-Rod’s performance.

CARP SAYS:

Welcome back, Sam. We missed you. A lot has happened since you were gone, as you may have surmised.

As for A-Roid, I’m not sure what questions need to be asked, because I’m sure a lot of the good ones won’t be answered. A-Rod is going to lie when he has to lie, and he’s going to dance around some of those “none-of-your-business” questions. Frankly, when somebody asks “did you take the steroids orally or have them injected into your $252 million butt?” I don’t blame A-Roid if he says, “none of your business.”

And what good is it for him to answer silly questions like that? He’s not going to tell us where he got the drugs, or from whom, and he’s not going to implicate anybody else in any way. He’s not going to tell us which of his former or current teammates were on the stuff. And when he’s asked if he used the ‘roids or the HGH before or since the admitted ‘01-03 period, he’s going to say “No” even if he has and/or still is using.

There is nothing A-Roid can say today that’s going to convince me he is not still using an undetectable drug, and today I am more firmly convinced that the usage is probably as rampant as ever, only now guys have smartened up to the point where they won’t get caught anymore.

And, frankly, I am quite tired of hearing how the Yankees have his back, and I think this whole idea of teammates showing up to support Rordiguez is a feeble attempt at intimidation. Also, I fully expect some idiotic questions, because this press conference is going to include media foofs from all walks, including news magazines, celeb shows, etc. It would have been better for A-Rod to do two press conferences, one for the actual baseball writers and one for everybody else. One where important, intelligent questions could be asked, and another that could have rivaled Super Bowl Media Day.

2:35 p.m., Sam says:
Sam Borden

First reaction to A-Rod’s meeting with the press? Mine was more of a feeling of incompleteness. Did A-Rod come clean? I guess so, but I think he also made some statements that were pretty unbelievable.

The notion that A-Rod was injected twice a month for three years by his “cousin” and was a) OK with that; b) unsure that he was doing anything wrong; and c) unclear on whether it was actually helping his performance seems borderline ridiculous. What was your first reaction?

CARP SAYS:

Part of me wants to believe A-Rod, to feel sorry for him, to buy his excuse that he was young and stupid, and mostly that he will, moving forward, make an attempt to “make the world a better place” by being involved in anti-drug programs.

I really do want to believe that. But for some reason, I give no credence to anything this guy says because he has proven to be such a louse when he leaves the baseball field, because of how he has treated his wife and family, how he couldn’t get out of the all-star game soon enough, how he pretty much takes the low road every time he reaches a fork.

He sounds sincere. Now he has to show me. And I’m not sure he can ever convince me that he’s clean and that he has changed in any way.

Also, Sam, I don’t know if you saw a classic letter from a reader in one of the New York papers this weekend. I’ll paraphrase because I don’t have it word for word, but it went: “I’m no doctor, but apparently steroids stop working on Oct. 1.”

You know, too, Sam, that this isn’t over. The cousin is now going to be checked out by all those investigative reporting teams. That’s just the start.

3:05 p.m., Sam says:
Sam Borden

That’s the thing – he alway messes things up. The idea behind this whole press conference was for A-Rod to address the issue and, hopefully, make strides to putting it behind him so the Yankees wouldn’t be distracted by it. Instead, Rodriguez added to his story – something he seems to do a lot, which is a curious practice for a guy who says he wants to be truthful – and created another layer to the whole scenario. Now there is going to be a mad rush to find out who this cousin is, where, exactly, A-Rod bought the drugs and who he talked to about it while it was going on. There’s also going to be investigation into A-Rod’s claim that he “dabbled” with amphetamines and “Ripped Fuel” while in Seattle, since amphetamines are now banned by MLB as well.

In other words, if A-Rod was hoping to start putting this issue behind him, he failed miserably.

This entry was posted on Tuesday, February 17th, 2009 at 9:44 am by Sam Borden. |

Advertisement

14 Responses to “Question #158: How did A-Rod do today?”

  1. jay destro

    my cousin got me this computer.

  2. Christina

    I agree with what you have said. He came off believable at first, but as he continued talking more and more, he became less believable to me. I mean even the whole Selena Roberts thing was annoying. He made it seem like they had a slight misunderstanding. He claimed she stalked him in NY and broke into his house in Miami. Then changes the story to well i misunderstood the police citation.

    I think hes gained fans that will believe this nonsense but to me he just made himself look worse.

  3. dadofjft

    He didn’t know what exactly it was, what the dosage should be and whether it was doing anything. That certainly sounds reasonable.

    Typical. Instead of putting this to bed he has added fuel to the fire. Good luck to his cousin (I didn’t even know he was related to Jose Canseco).

  4. randy l.

    “You know, too, Sam, that this isn’t over. The cousin is now going to be checked out by all those investigative reporting teams. That’s just the start.”

    if i was that cousin’s lawyer, i’d make sure that cousin is the Dominican Republic and stays there. i think it would be smart for him if he’s in the D.R. to give a statement with his lawyer present.

    i will be very surprised if he’s in the united states.

  5. Bronx Jeers

    This was the equivalent of Arod hitting that Baltimore chop at fenway a couple of years back.

    He’ll clain he got the job done but everyone else will think of how much better he could have done.

    I get the feeling this is not over. Really, Arod and the Yanks bungled this opportunity.

  6. Bob

    Sam, I love your stuff.

    It’s a shame though that Carp can’t act like a professional and refrain from using the immature/Tabloidesque “A-Roid” nonsense.

  7. Johannes

    I for one think he was as sincere as he has ever been, or ever will be.
    He handled himself well, he took his time and I believe him.
    The complete facts, however, might be lost forever.
    I am inclined to believe that a character like A-Rod can actually change in such a fundamental way over such a long time frame that they cant put themselves back in that former self and explains that persons actions.
    It might still be some denial, but the real A-Rod talked today.

    The positives here could hopefully become equal in proportion to the negative. He can become the face of all things anti-steroids! The spokesperson Baseball desperately needs. He could even lead the way to other players coming forward, the recipe for getting it over with is all laid out(short truth in controlled atmosphere followed by giant tent press conference where every stone is turned til it gets boring)!

    And he will undoubtedly have a fantastic season, for himself, for the fans, for the Yankees and ultimately for the skeptics and the supporters of erasing his numbers.
    I believe this is as good (or bad) as it is going to be.

  8. trisha

    Picky picky. It appears that I and the majority of others polled are satisfied with what we heard today:

    http://sports.espn.go.com/chat/sportsnation/poll/index

  9. Karen

    Wow, the range of expressions on A-Rod’s face as he read his statement was fascinating.

    Grimaces, frowns, squints (I’d start worrying about his eyesight, folks)...

    Personally, I think he just dug himself (and everyone else he mentioned: Gene Orza, his cousin) a deeper hole.

  10. The Truth Hurts: Rick 'Carp' is a dooshbag

    lol ‘Carp’

    Can’t take it?

    You call yourself a man?

  11. www.johnsterling.blogspot.com

    It Is High, It Is Far, It Is… Caught !

  12. Truly Apologize

    I truly apologize for the comments above, the previous four.

    I can say that I got your email and now reflect poorly upon my chosen words towards the Italian-American Sports Columnist that also writes on this blog.

    No disrespect was meant towards Mr. Borden.

    All hail Borden!

    All hail Abraham!

    I’m going to bed before I get in more trouble!

  13. MM35

    I am here to take my medicine today…

  14. Timmy R.

    Anyone where I can start my own blog.

Leave a Reply

Advertisement
About this blog
Rick Carpiniello and Sam Borden debate the hottest topics in sports.

Subscribe

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner





About the author
Sam BordenSam Borden grew up in Larchmont, graduated from Mamaroneck High School and has spent all 29 years of his life following the local sports scene. The drama of sports has always fascinated him, and his columns are designed to take a side or tell a story. The best days are the ones where he gets to do both.
Rick CarpinielloRick Carpiniello grew up in lower Westchester and began working in The Journal News' sports department (back when it was The Reporter Dispatch and eight other newspapers) in October of 1977 after a year of covering high school sports as a stringer. For more than 20 years he covered the New York Rangers and the National Hockey League. Carpiniello has been writing columns on everything from local sports to the big leagues since 2002.
Other recent entries

Recently Updated LoHud Blogs
Monthly Archives
Links



Bad Behavior has blocked 347 access attempts in the last 7 days.